One reader's rave

"Thanks for the newspaper with your book review. I can’t tell you how impressed I am with this terrific piece of writing. It is beautiful, complex, scholarly. Only sorry Mr. Freire cannot read it!" -- Ailene

Cassie Jaye, the day before I met her at the _Red Pill_ world premiere

Monday, September 30, 2019

Wikipedia.org Article on Tito Mukhopadhyay

From The Aspergian:

https://theaspergian.com/2019/09/30/wikipedia-org-article-on-tito-mukhopadhyay/





Editor’s Note: Anti-autistic Wikipedia editors have long been vandalizing and rewriting the narrative around autism and neurodiversity, with the most aggressive editing directed at non-speaking autistics.
As a result, many of their pages have been deleted.  The Aspergian, in an act of purposeful protest, is reposting the articles which have been removed.  We have added links to the author’s and organization’s personal sites, and encourage all autistics and allies to read more from non-speaking autistics.  Click here for other articles deleted from Wikipedia or to read about efforts to silence autistics.
Special thanks to Ren Everett for taking the lead on this project, to Malnormalulo for volunteering to help with non-speaking autistic advocacy, and to Tito and Soma Mukhopadhyay for their inspiration and working so hard to empower non-speaking autistics.

Tito Mukhopadhyay

Tito Rajarshi Mukhopadhyay (born 1989 in India) was diagnosed in early childhood with severe or low-functioning non-verbal autism.  He first came to the attention of the West through autism researcher Richard Mills, who met Tito in Bangalore, India[1] and arranged for him to travel to the UK to be assessed by his colleagues at the National Autistic Society and Lorna Wing.  At the same time the BBC made the documentary, Tito’s Story (2000), and the National Autistic Society published his first book, Beyond the Silence (2000).  He provides insights into the nature of his autism, according to Autism Speaks, the former Cure Autism Now, and scientists who studied his case, such as Michael Merzenich.[2][3]
Featured in the BBC documentary ‘Tito’s Story’ 1999 which won the Emma Award, UK Came to USA 2000 on invitation by Cure Autism Now Foundation 2000 to participate in Scientific research.  Featured in 60 minutes, Good Morning America, National Geographic Magazine, Scientific American, The New York Times, The Telegraph ( UK ), India Today, HBO Documentary ‘A Mother’s Courage’, and CNN. 
Tito’s mother, Soma, taught him reading and writing.[2][3] Cure Autism Now (now merged with Autism Speaks) sponsored Tito and his mother to travel to the United States so she could teach them her method, called the Rapid Prompting Method.[3]Tito’s first book, Beyond the Silence: My Life, The World and Autism, a collection of prose, poetry and philosophical texts, was published in 2000.  In the book, he reflects on how being autistic affects his view of the world.[4]
Tito has been featured on 60 Minutes, Good Morning America, Disability Studies Quarterly, the National Geographic Magazine, Scientific American, The New York Times, The Telegraph (UK), India Today, the HBO Documentary, A Mother’s Courage, and on CNN.

History

Tito was born in India and raised there by his mother Soma Mukhopadhyay.  His father lived and worked in another city, visiting occasionally.  When Tito was 18 months old, his mother noticed that he was not responding socially as other toddlers were.  He did not make eye contact as expected, he distanced himself from social settings, and he did not talk.[4]
Beginning when he was about 2 1/2 years old, Soma began intensively teaching him basic motor skills, such as pointing, by physically moving his limbs through the motions herself until he learned the movements.[6] After his autism diagnosis at age 3, she decided to continue educating him “using methods she would make up as she went along.”[2]
Soma noticed that her son had a good memory with roads and room layouts and would make complex patterns with match sticks.  She started trying to teach him to recognize numbers and letters on an alphabet board, then moved on to teaching him to draw them.  When he could not hold a pencil, she would secure one to his hand with a rubber band.  Soma also read classic works of English fiction to him, and since he began writing on his own at age 6, has urged him to write stories himself.[4]
From Scientific American journalist, Madhusree Mukerjee, Soma “observes him with profound intensity and snaps her fingers the moment Tito’s thoughts stray–which is all the time during my visit.  He seems to be beset by random neural firings.  If she didn’t intervene, Soma explains, he would write words from a different sentence in the middle of the one he already started.”[5]
In 1999, when Tito was 11, he and Soma visited the National Autistic Society‘s Centre for Social and Communication Disorders.  Researchers spoke with him, and observed him spelling out responses with a letter board independently.  He was assessed on the British Picture Vocabulary Scale, a test in which he had to point to one of four pictures to correctly identify the meaning of a word.  Tito’s score put him on par with 19-year-olds.[6]
While visiting, he demanded a promise that the book he had written would be published.[6] As requested, Breaking the Silence was published by the National Autistic Society the following year.[4]
In the time since, Tito has continued to write every day.  In his words, “I need to write.  It has become a part of me.”[4]
Tito continues to write daily, preferring to use handwriting over typing as a mode of communication.  His interests include literature and philosophy, and he credits Dr.  Ralph Savarese (literature) and Dr.  Erin Manning (philosophy) as being inspirational mentors.  He is an active Facebook user and responds to daily inquiries about autism, philosophy, and literature.

Misfit: A Poem by Tito Mukhopadhyay (2010)

There was the earth, turning and turning.
The stars receded, as if
Finding no wrong with anything.
Birds flew by all morning—
The sky lit
From the earth’s turning and turning.
My hands, as usual, were flapping.
The birds knew I was Autistic;
They found no wrong with anything.
Men and women stared at my nodding;
They labeled me a Misfit
(A Misfit turning and turning).
And then I was the wind, blowing.
Did anyone see my trick?
I found no wrong with anything.
Somewhere a wish was rising,
Perhaps from between my laughing lips.
Why stop turning and turning
When right can be found with everything?
Poem retrieved from Disability Studies Quarterly

Books

References

  1. ^ “Boy Sheds Light on Autism Mysteries”.  ABC News.  2006-01-06.  Retrieved 26 July 2017.
  2. Jump up to:a b c “Breaking The Silence, One Woman’s Drive To Teach Her Autistic Son – CBS News”.  CBS News.  2003-01-14.  Retrieved 2008-11-09.
  3. Jump up to:a b c “Autism Speaks, Get Involved, In the News”.  Autism Speaks.  Retrieved 2008-11-09.
  4. Jump up to:a b c d e Sandra Blakeslee (November 19, 2002). “A Boy, a Mother And a Rare Map Of Autism’s World – New York Times”.  New York Times.  Retrieved 2019-09-22.
  5. ^ Mukerjee, Madhusree (2004).  “A Transparent Enigma”. Scientific American: 49–50.
  6. Jump up to:a b c Wing, Lorna“Mind Tree Poems”Online Extra.  National Geographic Magazine.  Retrieved 26 July 2017.

Friday, September 27, 2019

Rape Researchers Ignore Legal Definitions, Occam's Razor


 
The headline says one in sixteen women's first sexual experience is rape. Reading the article, one discovers that only 28% of these were actual rape by the legal definition (leaving aside some that might be considered statutory rape, which isn't discussed). In other words the real figure isn't 1 in 16, but 1 in 57, similar to criminal justice statistics.

Aside from actual rape, the most clearly defined category of "coercion" described here consists of a girl's partner letting her know under what conditions he'll be interested in continuing the relationship. Of course girls tell their boyfriends this kind of thing too, but you aren't likely to find any studies about it, let alone see it mischaracterized as a crime.

The researchers appear to justify their incorrect usage by saying the consequences of not-as-defined-by-law "rape" can be traumatic, but no evidence is mentioned in support of this claim. (If one follows a few links, one can find a study claiming an “association” between “persuaded” sex and negative health outcomes. Occam’s razor might suggest this is because poor self-assertion/low self-esteem is the underlying cause of both, rather than because one causes the other.) And the negative mental health outcomes described aren't broken down by legal vs. non-legal definitions of rape.

Perhaps most concerning should be the fact that these purported scientists, by using the word "force" where no non-consensual contact occurred, are contributing to the campaign to redefine words as violence.

Thursday, September 26, 2019

Another Erotic Salon Is Coming Up!

I'll be reading a couple of my poems and reprising a song parody I previously performed in March for the benefit of hostess Susana Mayer, who wasn't present on that occasion.



New Office of Civil Rights Database

Title IX for All has launched an entirely new database focusing on Office of Civil Rights (OCR) resolution letters beginning during the Obama administration and onward. The announcement states:


While this OCR Database is joined at the hip with our Title IX Legal Database (which has also seen some minor upgrades with this release), it requires no access fee; user registration alone is needed.

Click Here To Enter The OCR Database

This database contains:

  • Tables of extensive OCR data distilled from hundreds of OCR resolution letters, including many not found on the OCR website and obtained by other methods (e.g., Freedom of Information Act requests)
  • Interactive reports providing at-a-glance summaries of broad or specific trends based on selectable criteria
  • A section tallying the frequency schools were investigated by the OCR relative to how many lawsuits were filed against those same schools by students accused of Title IX-related offenses
  • Analysis based on the study of over one million words of OCR resolution letters (yes, we counted), resolution agreements, and communication, including FOIA requests
  • An exploration of OCR regional office data
  • A guide to assist with navigating and understanding database features and terminology

Wednesday, September 25, 2019

Wikipedia.org Article on Sue Rubin

This article is copied from the The Aspergian.

Editor’s Note: Anti-autistic Wikipedia editors have long been vandalizing and rewriting the narrative around autism and neurodiversity, with the most aggressive editing directed at non-speaking autistics.
As a result, many of their pages have been deleted.  The Aspergian, in an act of purposeful protest, is reposting the articles which have been removed.  We will be adding links to the author’s and organization’s personal sites, and encourage all autistics and allies to read more from non-speaking autistics.  Click here for other articles deleted from Wikipedia or to read about efforts to silence autistics.

Special thanks to Ren Everett for taking the lead on this project and to Sue Rubin and her family for helping to provide additional resources.

Sue Rubin

At four, Sue Rubin was diagnosed with autism and mental retardation.  Rubin attended public day classes in special education until she was in high school.  At thirteen, testing at the 2½ year level, she was introduced to facilitated communication training, which begins with physical touch, emotional, and communicative support.

After five years, Rubin was able to type independently, graduating from high school with honors.  Rubin graduated from Whittier College in May, 2013, with a BA in Latin American History.  The only academic accommodation Rubin received was extra time on exams and homework.

Rubin has received many honors.  She carried the 1996 Olympic Torch in Los Angeles as a Community Hero.  She has also received a number of awards, including Cal-TASH’s 1st annual Mary Falvey Outstanding Young Person Award (1998), the Autism Society’s Wendy F.  Miller Award (1999) as the annual outstanding individual with autism, the Supported Life Institute Award (2000), and the Baron Inspirational Award from Vista Del Mar, LA (2011).  In 2002, Rubin joined Phi Alpha Theta, International Honor Society in History.

Sue has presented at over 100 conferences, workshops, and classes, was the subject of two PBS Life and Times programs, has had two articles published in the L.A.  Times, two in TASH Connections and one in Disability and Society, and has written chapters for the books Education for All: Critical Issues in the Education of Children and Youth with Disabilities; Autism and the Myth of the Person Alone, and Sharing Our Wisdom.

Sue was the subject and writer of the 2004 Academy Award-nominated, Autism is a World, and was featured in We Thought You’d Never Ask: Voices of People with Autism.  She was the subject of the article “My Mind Began to Wake Up” in Newsweek in 2005.  Sue was a community teacher for Included in the Picture, a series of documentary shorts created in 2019 at UCLA.  Sue also was an elected member of TASH’s National Board of Directors for two terms and served on the Board of Directors of Cal-TASH.

She is the owner and CEO of Sue Rubin Consulting, offering autism related presentations and consulting for various audiences.  She lives in Whittier, CA, with support, and enjoys an active social and cultural life.

References, Media Appearance, & Articles

Post Secondary Education” The Communicator, Spring, 2019, Vol.25, No.1
“We Thought You’d Never Ask: Voices of People with Autism”, 2009, DVD, The Hussman Foundation.  One of six people interviewed.
I Am Sue Rubin”, The Autism Perspective, Summer, 2005, Vol.1, Issue 3, 38-39.
Writer and subject of Academy Award nominated documentary, Autism is a World, appeared on CNN, May 22, 2004
My Mind Began to Wake Up,” Newsweek, Februay 28, 2005.
Featured in autism segment, KCET-TV, ”Life and Times” Oct.  23, 2002.
NLM Foundation Meeting on People with Autism as Self-Advocates,” TASH Connections, June, 2002, 28(6), 25.
“Matching a Thinking System to a Student,” TASH Connections, May, 2002, Vol.28.  No.5.  17
“Independence, Participation, and the Meaning of Mental Retardation,” Disability and Society, May 2001, 16(3), principal author, with D.  Biklen, C.  Kasa-Henrickson et al.
“My Experience with Inclusion: I Was Seen as a Competent Person.” National Association of Social Workers, California News, May 2000, 26(8), 19-21.
Subject of video, “Appearances versus Reality/ Success in College By a Low-Functioning Autistic Individual,” October, 1998.
“They Assured Me I Would Be Welcome”, The Rock, V.69, No.2, Summer 1998.
Subject of “Life and Times” segment, KCET, channel 28, aired July 15, 1997.
“My Own Story,” My Handi-Capable Reporter, V.1, No.9, Nov.  1996.
“New Frontiers” poem published in Tomorrow Never Knows,  The National Library of Poetry, 1995.
Subject of “Life and Times” segment, KCET, Channel 28, aired Dec.  20, 1995.
Interview on Cable Channel 65, “Long Beach Community Forum,” aired Dec.  4, 1995 and Dec.  15, 1995.
“Killing Autism Is a Constant Battle,” Los Angeles Times, Oct.  14, 1995.  (reprinted in several newsletters)
“Battling for the Disabled with Cesar Chavez in Mind,”Los Angeles Times, June 12, 1995.  (reprinted  in several newsletters)
Featured in Facilitated Communication training video,  More Than Meets the Eye, Chapman University, 1993.


Tuesday, September 24, 2019

Getting Censored Again

This time by vigilantes. I posted the following ad on Craigslist-Philadelphia:


I was notified yesterday at 1:22 pm that it had been posted and was now viewable. At 1:19 am today, I received a notification that it had been flagged for removal. When I followed the link from the first message again, I found that it had in fact been removed.

After posting a complaint about this on the Flagging Help forum, I soon received some replies. I've taken the suggestions in one of them to create and post a new version of the ad. Unlike the first, which I classified as community > politics, this one is in events:



Wednesday, September 18, 2019

Quote of the Month

"[A man's} wages must at least be sufficient to maintain him. They must even upon most occasions be somewhat more: otherwise it would be impossible for him to bring up a family, and the race of workmen would not last beyond the first generation." -- Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, quoted in Spencer A. Leonard, "Adam Smith, Revolutionary"

Sunday, September 15, 2019

Taking a Bow


I received this thank-you for having made a donation to the conference. Note: I checked the UNITE HERE! website -- they list Sheraton Suites Chicago O’Hare as a Fair Hotel.




ICMI 2019 was the biggest conference on men's issues ever and it's thanks to you!

Take a bow, you awesome person!

The dust has settled, the fur has flown, the x has y'd. Hopefully you are all safely back from your travels and comfortably ensconced in your regular lives.

By all accounts the 2019 International Conference on Men’s Issues, held in Chicago August 16th, 17th and 18th, was a roaring success!

This year’s conference organizer and underwriter, Honey Badger Brigade, would like to take a moment to thank everyone involved for helping make this the largest and most well attended ICMI to date.

We would like to thank our in-real-life attendees for taking the time and going to the expense of being there in the physical space and helping create the sense of community and support that is one of the primary purposes of these conferences. In many ways, it’s what happens between the speaker and panel content—the shared stories, the one on one conversations, the camaraderie engendered over a meal and a beer—that makes these events something to remember.

We’d like to thank our remote attendees and all others who wanted to be there but couldn’t for their support in the form of speaker sponsorships, remote tickets for the livestream, financial contributions, and your interest.

We’d like to thank our speakers and panelists, not all of whom are as interested in men’s issues as some of us veterans, but who share our ideals of freedom of speech, due process protections, equal justice for all, and basic human rights, and found ways to make their particular areas of interest relevant to our audience. We would particularly like to thank them for having the courage to be part of this event and relate their areas of expertise to men’s issues, even knowing the potential for backlash in their own lives and careers.

We’d like to thank the many, many volunteers who helped make this event successful. Being an usher and a go-fer, or a setter-upper and tearer-downer, is a largely exhausting and thankless task that never gets you the round of applause received by the stars of the show. But the show couldn’t have gone on without you, so thank you so much for your necessary contribution of time, energy and talent.

We’d like to thank Mike Buchanan for taking on the task of Emceeing the Rosemont presentation halls. And Paul Elam for being our toastmaster for catered events.

We’d like to thank Troy and Valerie for managing the public address system and the video stream, and Andrew for taking on the task of General Manager and putter-outer of fires. Even the biggest fire of all, the absence of ICMI 2019's chair due to US-Canada border shenanigans.

We’d like to thank Tom and Good Man Gone for getting video of all the presentations and panels and suggest you all help Good Man Gone cover ICMI 2020! And a shout out to Brian for providing invaluable video assistance to Tom during the event.

We’d like to extend a huge thanks to Fraser for putting together the design of the program book(if anyone needs a designer for a project, we’ll hook you up!) As well as assisting with the design for the stage sets.

Another enormous debt of gratitude for Grace, who put together the stage sets, ran general errands in the local area and filled in where and when she could!

Ed deserves praise and our gratitude for putting together the illustration work for the event. From the paratrooper badger character to the “meme-land” banner to innumerable promotional illustrations, Ed created an astounding visual aesthetic for the event! And if you’re ever in need of an artist, he's your man(ask us to pass you his info)!

We'd also like to thank Tim Goldich for not just speaking but wrangling up some volunteers. And we all would like to thank those volunteers from The Mankind Project who helped out with registration, ushering and general hospitality!

Finally we’d like to thank the Sheraton Suites Chicago O’Hare for hosting our event from start to finish, despite knowing what happened in Detroit in 2014, despite knowing we are unpopular in this political atmosphere, and despite fielding defamatory allegations on social media for having allowed us space lepers to congregate in their hotel.

When these allegations were made by our stalker on Twitter directly addressed to Sheraton Hotels—allegations that they were hosting a group of white and male supremacists and convicted rapists, and demands to know what Sheraton was doing to ensure the safety of women—Sheraton Suites Chicago O’Hare didn’t give in. We’d been there for two days by the time corporate called them to ask what was going on, and they’d had two full days getting to know us.

And as Karen discovered when asking one of the managers his thoughts on our conference the day after it concluded, he said our event was no different than any other conference the hotel had hosted. Our speakers, panelists and guests were nothing out of the ordinary—we respected the rules of the hotel, forgot to tip the servers no more often than anyone else, and were pretty much just normal people.
This is a HUGE endorsement given the current climate. Sheraton was literally fielding complaints on social media, many of them massively upvoted, accusing our movement of raping and murdering women during our events as a matter of course, all happening in a mainstream environment that sees deplatforming as a form of reputational salvation, and they didn’t fall for it.

In fact, the manager tried to reassure Karen that social media wasn’t anything to worry about. He went out of his way to assure her that the Sheraton was not worried about anything anyone at the conference had done, and that the accusations on social media were exactly that—accusations, unsubstantiated and nothing to be concerned about
So kudos to the Sheraton Suites Chicago O’Hare for standing by their contract with us, and standing by sanity.
If you have to travel for business and stay anywhere, I think the choice is clear. Seriously. Stay at the Sheraton, people!
Thank you everyone who made this event possible! We look forward to seeing you at the next event hosted by the Badgers!
Our deepest gratitude and love,
Alison Tieman
ICMI 2019 Chair and Founder of Honey Badger Radio

Karen Straughan
ICMI 2019 Promotions, GirlWritesWhat

Brian Martinez
ICMI 2019 Local Host and Production Manager of Honey Badger Radio
No really, thank you!
Honey Badger Brigade, 113 First Ave West, Kelvington, Saskatchewan S0A1W0,
Canada

Saturday, September 14, 2019

This T-Shirt Isn't Garbage

While selling One Step Away today, I saw a Penn student wearing a T-shirt with this graphic:

I stopped him to ask the specific reason he was wearing it, and he said, "Data mining." I asked if he uses DuckDuckGo and he said yes. I told him I do too.

Friday, September 13, 2019

Focus on What's Important


"In the past, Thunberg has spoken about being diagnosed with Asperger's — and how that has helped her.

"'My diagnosis helps me helps me see things a bit more clearly sometimes,' she says. 'When everyone else seems to just compromise and have this double moral that's, "Yeah. That's very important, but also I can't do that right now and I'm too lazy and so on." — But I can't really do that.'

"Thunberg continues, 'I want to to walk the talk, and to practice as I preach. So that is what I'm trying to do. Because if I am focused on something and if I know something, and if I decide to do something, then I go all in. And it seems like others are not doing that right now. So yeah, it has definitely helped me.'"

There's no focus like autistic focus. 😃


Tuesday, September 10, 2019

Keeping Culture Wars Out of the Neurodiversity Movement

The neurodiversity online magazine The Aspergian recently published a lengthy article about the so-called Autistic Dark Web, which consists of people on the spectrum who are hostile to the neurodiversity movement. Unfortunately it fell into the trap of ideological polarization that is probably part of the reason the ADW exists in the first place. I posted this comment below the article:

Since the Guardian piece was closed for comments, I posted mine here: https://dissenter.com/discussion/begin?url=https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/aug/26/autism-neurodiversity-severe

The article above does a service by exposing the bigotry and vested interests behind opposition to the neurodiversity movement. But it's marred by tangling this issue up with the ideological culture wars between the "Alt-Right" and "SJWs."
Naturally the genuinely alt-right have contempt for those of us who aren't "normal" and refuse to consider ourselves inferior. But their efforts to influence critically thinking people are aided when they're able to portray the ND movement as "infiltrated" by SJWs or the "Ctl-Left" as some have called it. This is not merely a pejorative term for anyone who is progressive or cares about social justice -- although, naturally, the alt-right will use it that way since it's in their interest to conflate all who are opposed to them.

Rather, these terms refer to a specific kind of ideology that is rooted in postmodernism and derogates open inquiry and critical thinking because it's based on a subjectivist epistemology. This is an ideology that is in fact anti-science and objectively constitutes an obstacle to progressive social change, notwithstanding that many of its adherents may consider themselves "radical" or even "anticapitalist." You can read a Marxist critique of it here: "Adolph Reed Jr: Identity Politics Is Neoliberalism" https://bennorton.com/adolph-reed-identity-politics-is-neoliberalism/ And here's one from a left-liberal or social-democratic perspective: "Identity Politics Does Not Continue the Work of the Civil Rights Movements" https://areomagazine.com/2018/09/25/identity-politics-does-not-continue-the-work-of-the-civil-rights-movements/

Because it falls into the trap of the Alt-Right/Ctl-Left dichotomy, the article perpetuates a good bit of misinformation. For instance, most of the Intellectual Dark Web is not Alt-Right but, rather, various shades of liberal. And #Gamergate was, in fact, about opposing corruption and political authoritarianism in videogame journalism, which is why it included considerable numbers of women, POCs, LGBTs, and people with disabilities: "Giving Voice to the Voiceless: The #NotYourShield Project" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tzwGIHUCtjU&t=2s "3 Women of Gamergate Fight Back!" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtzrUsi6Y1s&t=1s Liberal vlogger PSA Sitch has a good short allegorical explanation of what it was really about here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STl7-_f4_eA Oh, and one more thing: it actually won victories for ethics, as with this regulation that came out of the FTC: https://www.reddit.com/r/KotakuInAction/comments/38gocf/ethics_major_ftc_update_the_ftc_has_updated_their/ (Elsewhere, I saw actual acknowledgment from that agency that the #Gamergate-affiliated UV campaign was the reason for this reg, but unfortunately I didn't save the link.)

Half-Baked Thinking About Autism

A recent article in the Guardian claims, without offering any evidence, that the neurodiversity movement is "marginalizing" autistics who can't speak. Since comments have been closed on that page, I used Dissenter to post mine. You can read it here: https://dissenter.com/discussion/begin?url=https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/aug/26/autism-neurodiversity-severe

Gunning for the First Amendment

This looks like a pretty open-and-shut assault on First Amendment rights. Note in particular the sinister victim-blaming where they equate anticipating violence -- by others -- with advocating it.



https://www.npr.org/2019/09/10/759333549/nra-sues-san-francisco-after-lawmakers-declare-it-a-terrorist-organization

Tuesday, September 03, 2019

Read Poetry, Help Save a Life

"Cancel culture" has now taken a life in the form of Alec Holowka's suicide prompted by dubious and unproven allegations, made public in spite of the knowledge he was emotionally unstable and had suicidal ideation.

One way to counteract this dangerous trend is to affirmatively support those being mobbed and ostracized. I took a step yesterday by preordering Joseph Massey's book A New Silence. You can read about his cancellation here: https://quillette.com/2019/06/28/a-metoo-mob-tried-to-destroy-my-life-as-a-poet-this-is-how-i-survived/